Salomon XA PRO 3D Gpre-Tex Complete Review

The Salomon XA Pro 3D has long been a titan in the world of outdoor footwear. Initially engineered for the demands of adventure racing, its combination of rugged durability and supportive construction has earned it a loyal following among hikers, trail runners, and even casual wearers for over two decades. With the release of its 9th iteration, the XA Pro 3D V9 GTX, it's time to take a fresh look at this iconic shoe and see if it still holds up against the ever-evolving market.

Quick Take

Overall Rating: 4.4/5

Best For: Hiking, Trail Running, Backpacking

Key Strengths: Exceptional stability and support, Reliable waterproofing, Superior grip and traction, Durable construction.

Notable Limitations: Heavy for a trail running shoe, Stiff and firm cushioning, Potential for reduced breathability in warm conditions.

What Makes the Salomon XA PRO 3D Gore-Tex Stand Out?

So, what’s the secret sauce? Honestly, it's the shoe's incredible versatility and robust build. This isn't just a trail runner; it's a "do-it-all" hybrid that has carved out a niche for itself. The key lies in Salomon's 3D Advanced Chassis, a low-profile frame sandwiched between the outsole and midsole. This technology provides exceptional stability and support, making you feel sure-footed on even the most uneven and technical terrain.

Add to that the Gore-Tex membrane, and you've got a shoe that keeps your feet dry and comfortable in wet, muddy conditions, which is a huge plus for unpredictable weather. The Contagrip outsole is another highlight, delivering reliable grip on a wide variety of surfaces from wet rock to loose dirt. As one reviewer put it, "Thanks to its 3D Chassis and grippy outsole, we enjoyed an extremely stable and surefooted ride while testing this shoe, whether out for a light run or a backpacking journey".

Real Customer Experiences

The Salomon XA PRO 3D Gore-Tex generally receives positive feedback, but some common themes emerge in user reviews:

• Praise for Durability: Many users highlight the shoe's longevity, with some reporting their pairs lasting for several years of consistent use. One reviewer noted their older model lasted around 950 miles, which is impressive for a trail shoe.
• Love/Hate Relationship with the Quicklace System: While many appreciate the convenience and secure fit of the one-pull lacing system, others find it can loosen over time and the lace pocket can be small and fiddly.
• Mixed Feelings on Comfort: The firm midsole and stiff construction are a double-edged sword. While providing excellent support and protection, some users find them uncomfortable for long periods, especially those accustomed to more cushioned shoes.

"My foot remained dry and I just kept on hiking like nothing happened. If that's not perfect waterproofing then I don't know what is." - thetrek.co

"Very hard and uncomfortable shoes. After all day wearing and walking I fell like I'm wearing construction protective shoes. I try to give them a few times wearing chance, hope they gonna get softer and comfortable but now I'm regretting why I didn't return them." - Zappos.com Reviewer

Design and Build Quality

Let’s get into the nitty-gritty of what makes this shoe tick.

The upper is a combination of synthetic materials and 3D mesh, offering a blend of durability and breathability. The star here is the GORE-TEX membrane, providing a waterproof yet breathable barrier. Salomon's SensiFit system cradles the foot from the midsole to the laces, ensuring a snug and customized fit. This is all tied together with the iconic Quicklace system, which allows for quick and easy adjustments on the go..

Moving down, the midsole features Salomon’s EnergyCell or EnergyCell+ EVA foam, which provides good shock absorption and energy return. But the real hero is the 3D Advanced Chassis, a rigid frame that gives the shoe its signature stability and control.

The outsole is made of Salomon’s All Terrain Contagrip® rubber, designed for excellent grip on a variety of surfaces, from wet rocks to loose dirt. The multi-directional lugs add to this impressive traction.

In terms of weight, the XA PRO 3D GTX is on the heavier side for a trail running shoe, with the men's version weighing around 1 lb. 9.4 oz. (717g) per pair. While this contributes to its durability and stability, it might be a drawback for those seeking a lightweight, nimble feel.

Comfort and Fit

Let's talk about how the shoe actually feels on your feet. Comfort is subjective, but there are some common themes with the XA PRO 3D Gore-Tex.

For starters, it's a firm shoe. Don't expect a plush, pillowy ride here. The focus is on stability and support, which is great for tackling technical terrain but might feel a bit stiff for some, especially during the initial break-in period. One user mentioned, "After initial wear, I've had no issues with break-in", suggesting that while it might feel stiff at first, it can adapt to your foot over time.

When it comes to sizing, the consensus is a bit mixed. While around 80% of users find it to be true to size, others have noted that newer models might be longer or smaller than previous versions. It's always a good idea to try them on if you can.

The width profile is generally considered average to narrow. While the toebox is roomy at its widest point, it does taper towards the big toe, which could be an issue for those with wider feet. Fortunately, Salomon does offer a wide (2E) version for men.

Style and Versatility

One of the standout features of the XA PRO 3D is its versatility. It's not just a trail shoe; it's a style statement. The rugged, technical look has made it a favorite in the "gorpcore" trend, where outdoor gear is integrated into everyday fashion.

You'll see people rocking these shoes everywhere, from the trails to the city streets. They're stylish enough to wear with jeans or casual pants, and the waterproof GORE-TEX version is a practical choice for rainy days. The variety of colorways, from classic black to more vibrant options like "Blue Print/Surf The Web/Lapis Blue," means there's a style to suit almost everyone's taste. This blend of performance and aesthetics is what makes the XA PRO 3D a true crossover shoe.

Quality and Durability

Durability is where the Salomon XA PRO 3D really shines. It's often described as being "built like a tank" and is known for its long-lasting performance. The combination of a reinforced toe cap, abrasion-resistant mesh, and a sturdy chassis means this shoe can take a beating.

However, no shoe is perfect. A common complaint is the longevity of the GORE-TEX membrane. Some users have reported issues with the waterproofing failing after a few months of use. One user expressed their disappointment, stating, "After only a few months of mostly urban use, the inner lining at the heel area started to tear, and the Gore-Tex membrane began coming loose and bunching up inside the shoe". It's worth noting that Salomon does offer a warranty that may cover such issues.

Decision Matrix

Legend: ✓ = Good ○ = Average ✕ = Poor